I updated the pictures on 8/28/21, but these Creepy Finger Sandwiches have remained the same!
Happy Halloween!? Yay! I came up with these creepy finger sandwiches last year for a Halloween party, and now they have become a tradition. I love how simple and somewhat healthy these creepy sandwiches are. We are excited about Halloween this year because we might actually get trick or treaters. We are making homemade pizza and passing out/eating candy all night. Enjoy this throw back post and have a spooky Halloween!
All you need to create these are a loaf of extra thin sliced bread, black olives, and pimento cheese. Now here in Nashville we have a local company called Daddy Bob's making the best pimento cheese EVER! (I'm not getting paid to say that either!)
Now for the assembly of these creepy finger sandwiches. Mwahahaha!
Start by laying out all you bread, then slather on your favorite pimento cheese spread. Slice each sandwich into thirds or fourths.
Then press your thumb into one side of the bread to make a spot where the olive will lay.
I use Kalamata olive halves for the finger nails, but green olives would work too. Enjoy your creepy fingers! Mwahaha!
If you like this recipe you can rate it and leave a comment below. If you take a picture tag me on Instagram @hungrywaitress! Here's the recipe:Print